![]() |
| Judge Richard G Kopf |
I was reading this article about a judge that turned into his daughter,so he could be appointed to the Federal Bench. The crux of the article was him turning in his daughter to get the appointment. I understand that a father wants to help his daughter was involved in criminal activity. But, I thought what if the matter happen in Oz. Would the feeling be the exact same response. This question is one that came up with.
Let's say that Tony Abbott had a judicial nominee that was going to be appointed the next leg up the judicial hierarchy. What would the reaction be if a judge in the same situation had a son or daughter for that matter that was involved in criminal activity. Now, the crux of the dilemma is if you were same spot like you would turn your son or daughter in to get the appointment. Or would turn your son or daughter in and not take the appointment. I think is interesting question regarding familial relationships and the role of wanting to help but being caught in a spot.
If I had a son or daughter for that matter in the same spot., I would turn them in. But, I would not take the appointment for the simple reason of the way it would look. I don't want to appear selfish. There is a difference in wanting to help a loved one and doing it to get a coveted position. There has to be a clear distinction. I guest to how would Australians act if they had a judge in the same set of circumstances.
This question ask what is the most important thing to do. Is it turning a child in to get a promotion or doing the right thing of turning the child in and not taking the appointment. I would the Australian Legal Community this question how would they react if they were in the same set of circumstances.
Here is the link to the article because it does raise issues in my mind.
Judge Richard Kofp's Daughter and the hard choice
Let me know what you about the issue. I think it is good issue and it is one that concerns about where is the line that should not be crossed. How would handle it in the same circumstances.
If you like the information that has been presented, bookmark this page and the Law Ranger Blog in your favorites and send the link to it to everyone you know. Blog about it on Facebook, Twitter it to friends and family. That is the way it unfolds.



I know want to think like a lawyer and hit the ground running. This one of the many weapons that I will be using at law school.I am trying to is get a good handle being a good law student. I am hoping to be an even better lawyer when I do graduate.